Best Mattress Protectors for Airbnb and Vacation Rental

A mattress is quite an expensive investment for your Airbnb or vacation rental. At the same time, very exposed to wear and tear. Just one unexpected accident can leave your mattress with a permanent stain or odor. With the best mattress protectors for your Airbnb, your mattresses will be safe and protected.

Now, there’s a simple preventive measure that can save you from having to buy a new mattress. It saves you from a lot of headaches and cleaning. 

Before renting out your house, make sure you’ve protected all mattresses with a waterproof mattress protector.

In this article, I’ll show you the best mattress protectors proven by our everyday experiences and the positive reviews of many Airbnb hosts.

Best mattress protectors

These are the best mattress protectors we’ve tested and used, and they are also the go-to choice for many Airbnb hosts according to reviews.

Best Mattress Protector OverallUtopia Bedding Zippered Mattress Protector
Best Mattress Protector for ComfortSafeRest Mattress Protector
Best Budget Mattress ProtectorLINENSPA Top Mattress Protector
Best Cooling Mattress Protector MERITLIFE Premium Mattress Protector

While on Airbnb you have the option to choose a deposit, and you’re also covered with Aircover for damages.  However, you need to pass the process of documenting and submitting it all. If you want to find out more, check out our article on Airbnb Aircover – Airbnb AirCover: How To Claim Reimbursement With Success.

Best Mattress Protector Overall – Utopia Bedding Zippered Mattress Protector

The Utopia mattress protector stands out as our top choice due to its excellent balance of quality and price. It’s a bestseller, particularly favored by Airbnb and vacation rental hosts.

It’s affordable and able to securely protect your mattress with no unpleasant crinkly sound often associated with plastic sheets.

This zipped cover ensures comprehensive protection for your mattress from every possible angle. The only drawback of a zipped cover – it requires a bit more effort to put on compared to fitted sheet-style covers.


  • Zipped cover for 360 degrees protection
  • Waterproof
  • Noiseless
  • Very affordable
  • Machine washable and dryer safe
  • Bed bug and dust mite proof
  • Stretchable polyester fabric with a comfortable feel
  • Breathable
  • Odor protection


It takes a bit more time to zip a protector over the entire mattress.


Best Mattress Protector for Comfort – SafeRest Mattress Protector

Another bestseller is SafeRest premium mattress protector. This brand became a synonym for quality and ultimate comfort. 

This cover features two layers – a waterproof nylon sheet as its base, topped with a soft terry cotton surface. It is breathable, hypoallergenic, and provides a very comfortable sleeping experience.

Then, the fitted sheet style makes it easy to change sheets promptly, even when you need to do it in a hurry because new guests are about to arrive.


  • Fitted sheet for Easy installation
  • Waterproof
  • Extra comfort and soft
  • Hypoallergenic terry cotton surface
  • Noiseless
  • Machine washable
  • Bed bug and dust mite proof
  • Breathable
  • Odor protection


The price – you’re paying extra dollars for the added comfort of a terry cotton surface and consistent performance.

Best Budget Mattress Protector – LINENSPA Top Mattress Protector

Linenspa mattress protector deserves your attention if you seek an easy-to-maintain, reliable, and economical cover.

 It stands out as the most cost-effective mattress cover in its price range, with consistently positive reviews for its waterproof features and anti-plastic feel.

Reviewers highlight that this product is noise-free, offers effective protection, and, like the others mentioned here, is machine-washable.


  • Fitted sheet for easy installation
  • Waterproof
  • Affordable
  • Noiseless
  • Machine washable and dryer-safe
  • Bed bug and dust mite proof
  • Lightweight and Breathable
  • Smooth feel


  • Not recorded

Best Cooling Mattress Protector  – MERITLIFE Premium Mattress Protector

Here’s a SafeRest alternative worth trying if you want the best comfort for your guests – Meritlife Premium mattress protector. The top layer is soft and smooth, a blend of bamboo viscose and polyester, designed to provide a cool and fresh feel during sleep.

Enhanced comfort is crucial because guests spend a significant time sleeping and resting. It plays a role in what kind of reviews you’ll get.

If spending a few extra dollars ensures guests enjoy a comfortable night’s sleep without over-sweating or being disturbed by a plastic sheet’s crinkly sounds, consider checking out the Meritlife mattress protector.


  • Fitted sheet for Easy installation
  • Waterproof
  • Cooling effect
  • Moisture-wicking
  • Ultra soft 65% polyester and 35% Viscose from bamboo
  • Noiseless
  • Machine washable and dryer safe
  • Bed bug and dust mite proof
  • Breathable
  • Odor protection
  • 300-day Return/Replacement Service


The price is higher compared to budget options.

Types of mattress protectors

Mattress protectors fall into two categories: 

Fitted sheet style and

 Zipped style.

Fitted sheet protectors cover the top of your mattress and are easy to replace and wash when needed.

 On the other hand, zipped covers protect the entire mattress and are closed using a zipper.

Whichever style you choose, ensure you take the right measurements, as mattress protectors are designed for various bed sizes, including 

Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, and King.

What to look for in a mattress protector?

When considering a mattress protector, there are several key factors to keep in mind to ensure you choose the right one for your needs:


Look for protectors that are waterproof to guard against spills and stains.


Choose a breathable option to enhance airflow and regulate temperature during sleep, preventing over-sweating.

Noiseless feature

Noiseless protectors are a must, as they contribute to a peaceful night’s sleep without the disturbance of crinkly sounds. 

Size Compatibility

Ensure the protector fits your mattress size correctly. As previously stated, common sizes include Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, and King. 

Type of Protector

Decide between fitted sheet-style protectors and zipped covers. Fitted sheet-style protectors cover the top of the mattress, making them easy to replace and wash. On the other hand, zipped covers encase the entire mattress for comprehensive protection.

Material and Comfort

Consider the materials used for the top layer. For example, the Utopia Bedding Zippered Mattress Protector features a stretchable polyester fabric with a comfortable feel. The SafeRest Mattress Protector enhances comfort with its hypoallergenic terry cotton surface. The Meritlife Premium Mattress Protector offers a cooling effect with a blend of bamboo viscose and polyester.

Ease of Installation 

Consider the ease of putting on and taking off the protector. Fitted sheet-style protectors like the Linenspa and SafeRest are known for easy installation.

Mattress protector maintenance

Whatever brand you decide to go for, make sure the covers are machine washable and dryer safe. You need a kind of guarantee that your mattress protector can handle machine washing and yet maintain its waterproof ability.

As a vacation rental host, you’ll likely have to wash them more frequently with high guest turnover. This isn’t just because of spills and accidents but also because dust mites, bacteria, and sweat accumulate over time.

Normally, it’s advised to wash protective sheets quarterly. Keeping up with regular washing ensures a comfortable and hygienic environment for your guests.

A mattress protector lifespan- When will I have to replace it?

A manufacturer will indicate longevity. But as a rule of thumb, one mattress protector can serve you effectively for 2-3 years. 

For Airbnbs, maybe you can play safe and keep it for 1-2 years. Given the frequent turnover of guests and frequent washing, it’s important to follow instructions for washing and drying.

However, don’t wait until the cover completely wears out. When you see the first signs of damage, replace your mattress protector. It will cost you much less than a new mattress!

Signs that a mattress protector should be replaced

Holes and worn spots in your mattress protector are obvious signs it’s time to make a change. Tattered areas on the material mean weak protection against spills, bodily liquids, and dirt.

 And here’s the scoop: a worn-out cover can’t do its main job – keeping liquids out. So, keep an eye on your protective sheets. Having one extra in stock would be handy.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *